- Hot chocolate fondants with summer berries and mint froth
- Hot water crust game pie
- Ice box cake
- Iced peppermint and chocolate parfait
- Indian deep-fried soft-shell crab with lime pickle
- Indian spiced lamb with Provençal vegetables and mint sauce
- Individual beef Wellington with buttered spinach
- Individual pecan pies
- Individual scallop and monkfish pies
- Instant banana ice cream
- Instant coffee meringue gâteau
- Instant soufflé with caramelised bananas
- Irish coffee
- Irish soda bread
- Isle of Wight stuffed tomatoes
- Jam roly poly with proper custard
- Jam shortbreads
- James Martin beef stroganoff with sautéed potatoes
- James Martin Beef Wellington with wild mushroom Madeira sauce
- James Martin lemon drizzle cake